| NAME | POS. | YEAR | ALL AMERICAN AWARD | |||
| Kevin Short | CB | 2012 | First Team All-American | |||
| Dallas Buck | LB | 2012 | Academic All-American | |||
| Arthur Rucker | WR | 2012 | Academic All-American | |||
| Jermarcus 'Yoshi' Hardwick | OL | 2009 | First Team All-American | |||
| Lavonte David | LB | 2009 | First Team All-American | |||
| Jasmin Hopkins | RB | 2009 | First Team All-American | |||
| Coryell Judie | CB | 2008 | First Team All-American | |||
| Jacquain Williams | LB | 2008 | First Team All-American | |||
| Jason Pierre-Paul | DE | 2008 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Zac Dickey | QB | 2008 | Academic All-American | |||
| Justin Jenkins | LB | 2008 | Academic All-American | |||
| Arvell Nelson | FS | 2008 | Academic All-American | |||
| Brandon Martens | C | 2008 | Academic All-American | |||
| Sean Glades | DL | 2008 | Academic All-American | |||
| Lucien Antoine | DB | 2007 | First Team All-American | |||
| Rodney Lovett | RB | 2007 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Greg Cross | QB | 2007 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Jared Koechner | OL | 2007 | Academic All-American | |||
| Matt Glades | LB | 2007 | Academic All-American | |||
| Henry 'Scooter' Rogers | DB | 2006 | Second Team All-American | |||
| James Taylor | WR | 2001 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Bill Whittemore | QB | 2001 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Chris Brown | RB | 2000 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Bob Pesavento | QB | 1999 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Kevin Kemp | OL | 1998 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Jeremy McDaniel | WR | 1995 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Colin Harris | QB | 1995 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Frank Middleton | OL | 1994 | First Team All-American | |||
| Derrick Charles | WR | 1994 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Eldridge Williams | DB | 1993 | First Team All-American | |||
| Eldridge Williams | DB | 1992 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Trenton Ropp | TE | 1992 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Robert Reed | WR | 1992 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Andrew Swasey | DB | 1991 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Edward Fletcher | QB | 1990 | First Team All-American | |||
| Daryl Altic | P/K | 1990 | First Team All-American | |||
| John Henry | WR | 1990 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Paul Bland | TE | 1990 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Todd Scott | RB | 1989 | First Team All-American | |||
| Kelly Dennis | WR | 1988 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Eddie Brown | TE | 1988 | First Team All-American | |||
| Sean Fisher | QB | 1988 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Norman Goodman | TE | 1977 | First Team All-American | |||
| Wesley Williams | LB | 1976 | First Team All-American | |||
| Woodrow Carter | DL | 1975 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Steve Dill | DB | 1975 | Second Team All-American | |||
| C.E. Starkweather | LB | 1974 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Curtis Brown | RB | 1974 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Joe Ristau | OL | 1974 | First Team All-American | |||
| Rick Wieser | QB | 1974 | First Team All-American | |||
| Cliff Frazier | DL | 1973 | First Team All-American | |||
| Cliff Frazier | DL | 1972 | First Team All-American | |||
| David Dill | DB | 1971 | First Team All-American | |||
| Gary Lindsay | DE | 1971 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Jerome Hodges | OL | 1971 | First Team All-American | |||
| Jimmy Cunningham | DB | 1971 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Kurt Nieman | QB | 1971 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Tommy Reamon | RB | 1971 | First Team All-American | |||
| Jimmy Cunningham | DB | 1970 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Kurt Nieman | QB | 1970 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Tommy Reamon | RB | 1970 | First Team All-American | |||
| Jack Milligan | LB | 1970 | First Team All-American | |||
| Mitch Sutton | DL | 1970 | First Team All-American | |||
| Terry Stoughton | DB | 1970 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Steve Hall | K | 1970 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Ulysses Herber | RB | 1969 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Chip Harris | QB | 1969 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Melvin Gray | WR | 1969 | First Team All-American | |||
| Henry Noe | DL | 1968 | First Team All-American | |||
| John Brown | RB | 1968 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Stuart Mullis | DL | 1966 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Ken Brumley | QB | 1965 | First Team All-American | |||
| Paul Hartsel | OL | 1965 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Paul Hartsel | OL | 1964 | First Team All-American | |||
| Archie Loehr | E | 1963 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Adam McLean | DL | 1963 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Leroy Lewis | LB | 1963 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Tony Adams | DL | 1963 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Verna Green | OL/DL | 1962 | First Team All-American | |||
| Dennis Jones | QB | 1962 | Second Team All-American | |||
| John Putnam | FB | 1962 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Pat Batten | RB | 1961 | Second Team All-American | |||
| Joe Dawson | RB | 1958 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Don Meek | OL/DL | 1958 | Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Nate Beaman | 1947 | First Team All-American | ||||
| Richard Marti | HB | 1962 | Third Team All-American | |||